The Indian government has officially unveiled its definitive guidelines for assessing the "angel tax" on foreign investments in unlisted Indian shares. These regulations are designed to ascertain whether these investments carry a premium that falls under the purview of angel tax provisions.

Released by the finance ministry late on Monday, these ultimate rules aim to provide investors with much-needed clarity. They offer a range of valuation methods to choose from, ensuring a precise evaluation of the value of unlisted shares. This move is intended to prevent investors from inadvertently falling into the angel tax trap—a preventive measure that was expanded to encompass non-resident investors in the Finance Act of 2023.

According to the Income Tax Act, share premiums received by entities lacking significant public interest are deemed taxable as 'income from other sources.' Start-ups have raised concerns that this taxation approach hampers their capital-raising efforts, as many of these entities negotiate the dilution of their stakes in the company based on the company's future valuation. By introducing flexibility in valuation methods, the government seeks to ensure that the company's future prospects are also factored into its valuation for tax purposes.

The Income-tax (Twenty-first Amendment) Rules of 2023, which amend Rule 11UA, came into effect on Monday. These rules specify that the fair value of shares will be determined using the prescribed methods. Anything above this value, accounting for a 10% safe harbor margin, will be considered a taxable premium. These revised rules also introduce a mechanism for determining the fair market value of Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS) for investments from both residents and non-residents.

Experts have welcomed these rules, citing their flexibility for investors. The amendments to Rule 11UA of the Indian Income Tax Act bring several positive changes, including flexibility through multiple valuation methods, simplification of valuation date considerations, incentives for venture capital investments, facilitation of investments from notified entities, clarification on CCPS, and encouragement of foreign investments, as noted by Amit Agarwal, a partner at Nangia & Co LLP.

The incorporation of a tolerance threshold for minor valuation discrepancies enhances the efficiency and fairness of tax assessments, benefiting both taxpayers and the government, according to Agarwal.

Amit Maheshwari, Tax Partner at AKM Global, a tax and consulting firm, acknowledged the significance of these new rules, particularly in the context of the Compulsorily Convertible Preference Shares (CCPS) valuation mechanism. Most venture capital funds invest in India through the CCPS route. However, Maheshwari also noted that the implementation of these rules will be closely monitored, as valuation remains a subjective matter with various methods and approaches, potentially increasing the risk of litigation.

What is Angel Tax: Angel tax, officially known as the "Income Tax on Share Premium," is a term used to describe a tax levied by the Indian government on the excess capital that start-ups raise when issuing shares to investors at a premium. Under Indian tax law, if a start-up's share price exceeds its fair market value, the difference is treated as income and subjected to taxation, which can be as high as 30%. This tax has been a contentious issue as it was seen as discouraging investment in start-ups and hindering their growth. In response to industry concerns, the Indian government has periodically revised and clarified the rules surrounding angel tax to alleviate its impact on early-stage companies and investors.

Decline in New Frontline Jobs in India in FY23 Due to Macroeconomic Challenges: Report

Dollar Nears Six-Month High as Central Banks Weigh Decisions