Killian Dain vs. Lars Sullivan vs. Aleister Black vs. Johnny Gargano - All four waste no time going at it. Black sends Sullivan outside and hits a kick on Dain. Black goes for a moonsault but gets caught and thrown to the apron. Gargano tries for the same and gets caught as well. Finally Dain hits a suicide dive and takes his fellow big man down. Time for a break.

Aleister Black and Gargano back in the ring and receive dueling chants. Gargano goes for his slingshot spear but is met with a kick instead. Gargano avoids a leg sweep and hits a thunderous super kick. He uses a twirling head scissors into the Gargano Escape but Dain reenters the match with a senton. Dain with a power bomb and elbow drop to Gargano but Black breaks up the pin. The beast of Belfast now working on Black and heads up top. Black tries to take Dain down but it takes the aid of Gargano to get him down. All three men down as Sullivan rises from the ashes to head back to the ring.

Sullivan takes on all comers and rids the ring of the smaller competitors. It's now a faceoff between Dain and Sullivan. They each sustain shots from the other but pop right back up. Black hops back in and uses his precise striking to take a quick advantage where he has both men reeling. Black hits Black Mass and goes for the cover, but Undisputed Era comes out to break up the pin for revenge on Black taking Cole out of the tournament. Gargano comes to the aid to take out UE and tries to get Black back in the ring for a cover. Sullivan swings and misses and goes into the steps. Dain lifts Gargano up but Johnny reverses and sends Dain into Lars on the stairs. Gargano hits a leaping DDT over the top rope and gets the surprise three count. The crowd goes bananas for the unexpected result.

Winner and NEW #1 Contender: Johnny Gargano