England: English cricket desperately needs reform because of "widespread and deep-rooted" racism, misogyny, elitism, and class-based prejudice that exists at all levels of the game.
More than 4,000 players, coaches, administrators, and fans provided testimony for the Independent Commission for Equity in Cricket (Icec)'s 317-page report, which asks the sport to accept "that it's not banter or just a few bad apples" to blame for the issues.
Also Read: Road to World Cup Qualifiers: Drama Unfolds as Qualifiers Eliminate Four Teams
In response to the report, the England and Wales Cricket Board issued an unequivocal apology for failing to fully address discrimination and called the conclusions "a seminal moment" for the game. Within three months, it promised to address the 44 suggestions given by Icec.
However Cindy Butts, the Icec chair, said that fundamental change was quickly needed. “Our findings are unequivocal,” she said. “Discrimination is both overt and baked into the structures and processes within cricket. The stark reality is cricket is not a game for everyone.
“Racism, class-based discrimination, elitism and sexism are widespread and deep rooted. The game must face up to the fact that it’s not banter or just a few bad apples.”
Also Read: On and Off the Field: Hardik Pandya's Swanky Cars Turn Heads
The report, which is one of the most blistering published evaluations of a British sports organisation, exposes the depth of the sport's flaws, citing things like:
“At the playing level, private school educated players are disproportionately represented, to a significant extent, in England’s national teams, both men and women, compared with the general population,” the report reads. “Diversity of ethnic background has also decreased in the men’s professional game over the last 30 years, and has never been high in the women’s game.”
The Icec’s 44 recommendations range from the modest to the radical. They include a number of measures to tackle racism, sexism and elitism, as well as calls for regular “culture” checks to ensure genuine change. “Cricket must not find itself in the same position in another two years’ time let alone another twenty,” the report states.
Also Read: ICC to Announce Schedule for ICC ODI World Cup 2023 in Mumbai Event
In order to prevent the ECB from having a conflict of interest by serving as both a promoter and a regulator, the Icec study also proposes for the creation of an independent regulator.
It also suggests that the annual Harrow vs. Eton match and the Varsity game between Oxford vs. Cambridge be replaced by a state school under-15s competition and a finals day for university teams to signify that the sport is becoming more inclusive. This suggestion will no doubt send some traditionalists into a frenzy.
“Some people may roll their eyes at the perceived ‘wokeness’ of this work,” the report states. “However, as much as the word may have been weaponized in recent years, taking on a pejorative meaning, we consider – and it is often defined as such – that being ‘woke’ or doing ‘woke work’ simply means being alive to injustice.”
Butts served as the Metropolitan Police Authority's deputy chair and as a former commissioner at the Criminal Cases Review Commission. She also serves as a trustee for the Kick it Out football charity, which fights racism. The former Conservative Prime Minister Sir John Major wrote the report's foreword.
Some suggestions, such as dramatically increasing the chances for state school athletes, could be financially difficult to implement. The commission also points out that in 2021, England's male cricket players were paid 13 times as much as the country's female players, and it recommends equal pay at the provincial and international levels by 2030, both of which may be challenging to achieve.
The report recognises the bravery of the ECB in commissioning the report in March 2021, and acknowledges the game has made some sizeable improvements recently, particularly in attracting more girls and women players. It also accepts that the problems it identifies are “not, sadly, unique to cricket” and are often indicative of “deeply rooted societal problems”.
However the ECB chair, Richard Thompson, said he recognised that the game had to do far more to significantly reform. “Cricket should be a game for everyone, and we know that this has not always been the case,” he said.
“Powerful conclusions within the report also highlight that for too long women and black people were neglected. We are truly sorry for this. I am determined that this wake-up call for cricket in England and Wales should not be wasted.”
Also Read: Franchise Cricket vs. National Duty: Legend Clive Lloyd's Perspective